6 selective schools · Maine
Best Colleges in Maine
Ranked by acceptance rate. Real published data.
Calculate your odds at any schoolWhat is the most selective college in Maine?
Colby College currently has the lowest acceptance rate among selective Maine schools at 7.1%. The average acceptance rate across these 6 Maine institutions is 9.2%.
Ranked by Acceptance Rate
| # | School | Accept | SAT | Net price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Colby CollegeWaterville, Maine | 7.1% | 1460–1550 | $17,180 |
| 2 | Colby CollegeWaterville, ME | 7.1% | 1460–1550 | $17,180 |
| 3 | Bowdoin CollegeBrunswick, Maine | 7.1% | 1470–1550 | $14,398 |
| 4 | Bowdoin CollegeBrunswick, ME | 7.1% | 1470–1550 | $14,398 |
| 5 | Bates CollegeLewiston, Maine | 13.3% | 1420–1530 | $29,351 |
| 6 | Bates CollegeLewiston, ME | 13.3% | 1420–1530 | $29,351 |
Source: U.S. Department of Education College Scorecard. Last verified May 2026.
Standouts in Maine
The Maine Selective Landscape
Maine has 6 selective universities and colleges in this dataset: 6 private institutions. Acceptance rates range from 7.1% at Colby to 13.3% at Bates, with a state average of 9.2%.
In-State vs. Out-of-State: The Hidden Discount
Public university acceptance rates published nationally aggregate in-state and out-of-state applicants. The actual rates split substantially. Most Maine public flagships admit in-state residents at acceptance rates 10–25 percentage points higher than their published headline numbers. The reverse is also true: for out-of-state applicants, the effective acceptance rate at these schools is often well below the published figure.
Tuition follows the same logic. Maine residents typically pay $20,000–$30,000 less per year at in-state public universities than non-residents. Combined with state-specific aid programs, that gap often makes a state flagship the highest-ROI option for in-state students even when private schools meet 100% of demonstrated need.
How to Use This List
Acceptance rate is the most direct selectivity signal but tells you nothing about your personal odds. Schools with similar admit rates can have very different admitted-student profiles. Maine has a mix of national-tier privates, in-state flagships (with substantially higher admit rates for residents than non-residents), and selective liberal arts colleges. Each plays a different role in a balanced college list.
For most in-state Maine applicants, the right college list mixes one or two reach privates, a flagship public as a target with strong odds and low net price, and at least one safety. Use the calculator to estimate your personal odds at each before deciding which to ED.
FAQ
What is the easiest college to get into in Maine?
Among selective Maine institutions tracked here, Bates College has the highest acceptance rate (13.3%). For broader admissions options, the in-state community college and CSU/SUNY/state university systems offer significantly higher admit rates than these competitive schools.
Are in-state public schools easier to get into than the published rate?
Yes, often dramatically so. Public flagships report aggregate acceptance rates that mix in-state and out-of-state pools. In-state residents typically face acceptance rates 10–30 percentage points higher than the headline number. Out-of-state applicants face rates lower than the headline. Check each school's Common Data Set for the residency-split breakdown.
Should I apply to schools outside Maine?
Most students should apply to a mix. Private universities have no in-state preference (Harvard treats a Maine applicant the same as a Wyoming applicant). Out-of-state public flagships typically charge much higher tuition. The right balance depends on your odds, financial picture, and willingness to leave home.